Aged Eggnog
15mtime
8-10serves
Crewsowner
★★★★★1 cook
Alton Brown's aged eggnog: rum, cognac and bourbon blended with yolks, sugar and nutmeg, aged in two phases for about 90 days. Strong, rich, and a great holiday batch if you start by mid-October.
Ingredients
- eggs (12 large)
- Jamaican rum (1 cup)
- cognac (1 cup)
- bourbon (1 cup)
- whole milk (2 cups)
- sugar (1 lb)
- whole nutmeg (1 tsp total, grated)
- half-and-half (2 cups)
- heavy cream (2 cups)
- two 2-quart jars with lids, and a 3-quart container
Method
- Separate the eggs and put the yolks in a 2-quart container. Save the whites for something else (souffle, macaroons, angel food cake, pavlova).
- Combine the rum, cognac and bourbon in a vessel with a pour spout.
- Add the milk, sugar and nutmeg to the yolks and blend with a stick blender until smooth, keeping the head submerged to avoid foam.
- With the blender running, slowly pour in the spirits until fully combined.
- Lid it and refrigerate 30 days (two 2-quart jars with tight lids are easier to stash). Shake now and then.
- Phase 2: recombine into a vessel that holds at least 3 quarts. With the blender on medium, slowly add the milk, half-and-half, cream and nutmeg until smooth.
- Lid it and refrigerate another 50-60 days, shaking occasionally.
- Serve straight from the fridge. Unopened jars keep at least 6 months.
Notes from us
Start by mid-October for Christmas: 30 days for phase 1, then 50-60 for phase 2.
Cook diary
- Nov 2, 2026, Crews, 5/5